How to Spot High-Quality Cashmere

What Makes High Quality Cashmere Stand Out?

High quality cashmere starts with small but meaningful choices: the origin of the fibers, the finesse of the knit, even how a sweater breathes against your skin on a damp morning. Not all cashmere is created equal. There’s the stuff that pills and thins after a handful of wears, and then there are pieces that almost seem to get better with time, like they remember your shape and warmth. A good Italian-made cashmere sweater feels different right from the start. The yarn is combed from undercoats of goats raised in remote, sometimes wildly beautiful regions. Once it’s in the hands of seasoned Italian artisans, things get personal. They spin and knit it in small batches, the way their grandparents did. We’ve noticed those really stand-out knits have a weight that gives comfort, but never feels heavy. It reminds us of a favorite old hardcover, reliable, softly worn, and crafted to last. When searching for high quality cashmere, begin with that feeling in your hands and trust your instinct about materials that invite a second touch.

Look Close: The Fiber Tells a Story

When it comes to recognizing high quality cashmere, take a closer look at the yarn itself. Pluck up a little courage and gently pinch the fabric: proper cashmere should bounce back, not sag or stick. It’s sort of like testing a peach at the market, just the right resistance. If you examine a piece such as our lemon Links Stitch V-Neck (which you can find right here), you’ll notice the surface feels plump but never fuzzy. That’s a sign of longer, finer cashmere fibers, which lead to fewer pills down the road. The right knit should have tiny, evenly-spaced loops; nothing loose or uneven. Think of that careful precision as a little love letter from an Italian artisan—a detail you can sense if you pay attention.

Weight and Warmth: Discover the Difference

A true high quality cashmere sweater hits a specific sweet spot: it feels cozy even in a drafty old house, but never stifles when you step outside. Not all knits get this right. Many lightweight options trade away warmth for thinness, while some overly dense ones are bulky and lack that delicate drape. Italian know-how is really apparent here. The best artisans have been playing with tension and fiber for generations to get a result that feels clean against bare skin and works whether layered for a New York winter or worn solo in a Milanese spring. One small hint you’re holding the good stuff? It just sits right, over your shirt sleeve or blended into denim and boots—never saggy, never rigid. The tactile memory of a fine cashmere turtleneck, like this classic black version, stays with you throughout the day, carrying warmth without weight.

Feel Matters More Than Flash

There’s a kind of quiet confidence in a sweater that isn’t trying to scream its value. We believe you can recognize high quality cashmere by how it feels on your body and in your hand. The sensation is hard to forget, soft, sure, but also a bit springy and cool to the touch at first, warming naturally as you move. A lower quality version, especially when mass produced, often feels flat, scratchy, or airy, sometimes snagging with jewelry or watches. Our team has spent a good amount of time hunting out sweaters across Italy, and it’s surprisingly rare to find one that combines a generous feeling with understated looks. Pieces like our women’s classic turtleneck don’t rely on shimmer or embellishment—just clean lines, honest fibers, and the sort of polish you find in old favorites that lasted for decades.

Choosing Well-Made Italian Cashmere

If you want to find truly high quality cashmere, look for signs of care at every stage, from the source of the yarn to the final press before shipping. At Monticelli, every piece carries a bit of the Tuscan calm, unhurried and thoughtfully finished by hands that have practiced the same stitch for years. Our brown crew necks show this approach—a kind of timeless, lived-in beauty you just can’t get from fast fashion. Honest transparency about materials and production, and a willingness to wait for a made-to-order knit, matter just as much as the initial feel. To see more of what Italian craftsmanship looks like up close, take a look at our crew neck collection here. The best part of high quality cashmere is how your appreciation grows the longer you live with it—a quiet partnership, a little like home.

Other Blog Posts You Might Like

If this topic resonated with you, here are a few more stories we think you’ll enjoy:

• Color spotlight camel cashmere wrap
• Best cashmere sweaters for travel
• Is cashmere worth it